Alternative Energy on a Finite Planet
environmental studies
about this course
Transition to carbon-free electricity is central to addressing climate change. These are generally solar, wind, hydro and nuclear – often termed ‘renewables’, ‘green’ or ‘sustainable’. The use of such terms conceals the substantial limitations and impacts of these alternative sources of energy. Energy extraction by solar panels and wind turbines (i.e. their efficiency) are inexorably limited by fundamental physics. Their power densities are substantially lower than those of fossil fuel power plants, and therefore require correspondingly larger land areas for installation relative to a fossil fuel plant of equivalent output. Unless the installation is on degraded land, they can cause serious disruption to wildlife habitats and agricultural lands. We have already witnessed the deleterious impacts of large hydro projects in parts of the country, and those of nuclear energy in other parts of the world. The raw materials that alternative energy installations are composed of and constructed from – metal ores, plastics, minerals – are in finite supply. Many are concentrated in certain parts of the world (e.g. Lithium in Chile, Nickel in Indonesia), therefore subject to the vicissitudes of geopolitics (and pandemics). Large solar and wind power farms also substantially affect the microclimate of their installation sites causing local warming. It is also unclear how the vast – and exponentially rising – quantities of spent solar panels and wind turbines that will emerge within the decade can be effectively recycled. The intermittency problems of solar and wind power are well known, and therefore the need for battery technology – with its own land, water, material and chemical footprints. What does all this mean for India’s ambitious alternative energy programme of 500 GW of non-fossil energy by 2030? What will it affect carbon emissions, air pollution, wildlife, agriculture, and human settlements? This course will be a joint exploration of many such questions.
This is a **quantitative course** but pitched at high school level of mathematics. The goal of the course, subject to interest and coding skills, is to divide into teams and create maps of India identifying the regions with greatest potential for alternative energy with least impacts – from interwoven science, socio-economic, and ecological perspectives.
in these programmes
- environmental studies
elective · 4-year major, 4-year double major, 3-year major, 3-year double major, 4-year minor, 3-year minor, concentration (4-year), concentration (3-year)
planning & teaching
before this
No prerequisites.
recently taught by
- Chirag DharaAssistant Professor, Environmental Studies
Recorded in 2025 T3, 2024 T2. Instructors may change.